Soldier for life?

Soldier for life?

As I sit here on my first day out of the Army, I continue to contemplate the Soldier for Life mentality/ program/ concept.  I may ruffle some feathers here and that’s good as this is meant to generate a discussion.

I’m not a Soldier for Life, it’s a chapter in my life.  A very large portion but not my whole life nor will I let my service solely define me. Is it the wrong mentality to keep pushing the mantra of the soldier for life on soldiers?  When everything in the transition dictates transform into a civilian, reintegrate into “normal” America and leave being a soldier behind. 

Think about it:

•    No LinkedIn picture in uniform

•    Lose the acronyms and military terminology

•    Use civilian business terms

•    Stop calling everyone sir or ma’am

•    Relate military experience to civilian jobs

•    Put the uniforms in the closet and put on civilian attire

•    Don’t walk down the hall with a coworker in step 


In my mind, its be proud of our service, look back at it with fondness, share our experiences and translate the skills we learned serving our country.  But when we leave the gate the last time, we are no longer soldiers.  The more we think we are still a soldier, the more we will set ourselves back in our transition to civilian life and the mental shift that needs to happen.  We must stop being a soldier and be a civilian for the rest of our lives.  Otherwise, we are hanging on to our past like the 55-year-old guy at the local bar talking about his high school football career.  We all know how well that guy sounds and looks.

I agree that we should encourage others to serve and be mentors for young people.  That is why we need to share our experiences, both the good and the bad.  Inform others about our service and the many once in a lifetime moments (yes many) we have had the privilege to be a part of.

I believe everyone acknowledges that we have a veteran suicide problem.  One is too many and the number is greater than one this year by far. If the individual solely identifies as a soldier and the charade is pushed on them that they will be a soldier for life, what happens when that’s not true.  When their team, squad, and platoon is no longer around.  When they drive out the gate and they don’t exist to the Army anymore (not a knock on the army, they have to worry about the people in service).  When they can’t find their purpose in life from being a soldier.  When there is no next mission to train and prepare for. When there is not a clear path to promotion.  When there is no morning formation and PT run to wake up for.  When you’re not freezing cold and pulling security in a faraway land, laughing with your buddy about how crazy the situation is.  When they are not commended for making things happen. When they are not mentored and counseled for professional and personal growth.  When they are not making a difference.  The list can keep on going for each individual service member.

Why is the Army pushing the Soldier for Life program? Why the unicorns and rainbows, false motivation to make people feel good about themselves?  Like everyone gets a beret and that will improve esprit de corps.  

But hey, you get literature and a bumper sticker saying “Soldier for Life.”  Hooah!




Carl Whyte, MAS, SFPC, CPD

Security Specialist at HQ USA INSCOM

5y

Herb I just saw your posts and they all inspire me. I am 6months 16 days from retirement and I am struggling with the taught of not being a soldier. I am the same person who always preach that this machine has been around for 200+ years and will be around long after us so we have to prepare for that curtain call. Some days are better than some but for the most part I just cant get past not being a Soldier. So seeing your posts give me a shove to get myself together. Thanks for still serving with your wise wisdom.

Tony Miller

Director, Ocean Science and Technology at Peraton

5y

Well done Herb.  I loved the Navy and I wore the uniform for almost 30 years, but I always tell people that the military is a temporary gig.  No matter how long you stay, we all get out.  Almost nobody actually retires.  So then we have to go over to the other side and if you want to succeed on that side you have to learn how to dress and speak the language.

Like
Reply

Very well written and great perspective from a soldiers side. Also, the things you point out, (the comradery, the ability to know and see clearly what to do for that next promotion), are some of the very things I wish corporate life had more of. It’s confusing and lonely at times even for someone who’s not served. But that’s where I hope I can help “lead the way”,no pun intended, for those transitioning like you Herb Thompson, CPD.

To view or add a comment, sign in

More articles by Herb Thompson

  • What will we see on Veterans Day?

    What will we see on Veterans Day?

    It’s almost Veterans Day, the day out of the year set aside to recognize veterans for their service to our country. The…

    81 Comments
  • To Those That Doubted Me, Thank You!

    To Those That Doubted Me, Thank You!

    We all have doubters. What matters is what you do with that doubt.

    5 Comments
  • Military Transition: A World Without Rank, Tabs, or Tridents

    Military Transition: A World Without Rank, Tabs, or Tridents

    This article is a collaboration by Jared French and Herb Thompson. We should aspire to work for Leaders, not just…

    23 Comments
  • Masters of the basics. A list to master.

    Masters of the basics. A list to master.

    We are successful in our missions because we are masters of the basics. Transitioning out of the Army should be no…

    8 Comments
  • War stories are cool, but…

    War stories are cool, but…

    Transitioning Green Beret’s possess excellent skills and experiences to bring value to a new organization upon their…

    19 Comments
  • We need to be hustling.

    We need to be hustling.

    As much as I hate sports clichés and this will date me a little bit, but when I think of hustle, I think of Pete Rose…

    6 Comments
  • Yeah, it’s a fit

    Yeah, it’s a fit

    How can I tell you if something is a good fit? A former US Supreme Court Justice, Potter Stewart, in 1964 essentially…

  • What do you want to be when you grow up?

    What do you want to be when you grow up?

    This is kind of the question I asked myself approaching retirement from the Army. Honestly up until that point I had…

    2 Comments
  • Are you owed anything?

    Are you owed anything?

    Plain and simple NO. Let me repeat it, YOU ARE NOT OWED ANYTHING! It doesn’t matter that you’re a veteran, especially a…

  • The GMAT and GRE for an MBA

    The GMAT and GRE for an MBA

    Let’s state the obvious right now, taking the GMAT or GRE sucks. However, if you want to get into a reputable in-person…

    4 Comments

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics