Top-Rated Keurig Coffee Maker Machines 2024

When it comes to the best coffee makers, Keurig is a top contender. It is known for its user-friendly machines and the innovation of K-Cups. Whether you're a fan of a strong morning brew or a quick espresso pick-me-up, Keurig has a range of machines designed to cater to your specific needs and preferences.

At Top Reviews, we're fond of the Keurig brand, and our team has rigorously tested various models to bring you this comprehensive guide. Each machine was tested for at least two weeks, evaluating setup, usability, and maintenance.

Keep reading to discover our top selections, including our overall favorite. If you're interested in the best pod coffee makers, we also have a guide comparing our top picks.

1. Keurig K-Café Special Edition Single Serve Coffee Maker

This K-Café Special Edition Single Serve Coffee Latte & Cappuccino Maker is a convenient way to get barista-quality drinks at home, making it a great choice for coffee lovers. This versatile machine has a milk frother, so you can make lattes and cappuccinos based on your cup size, strength, and temperature preferences.

It's not a great design, being available mainly in silver, but it's larger than typical Keurig machines, which makes it a great product at a great price. The user-friendly light-up display makes it easy to navigate and understand the different functions available, which is a significant advantage for both new and experienced users.

Because of its size and extra features like the milk frother, our reviewer thought the K-Café was more complicated than other Keurig machines. But they got used to it pretty quickly, appreciating how quickly it heated up and how quiet it was.

Compared to other models like the K-Duo, the K-Café stood out for its easy way to control coffee strength. It tasted great, and our reviewer was really happy with it. K-Café Special Edition is a great coffee maker for coffee lovers who like brewing the perfect cup despite the steeper learning curve.

With the milk frother, users can get the best coffee experience, leaving them happy with every sip. Anyone who values quality and customization in their coffee routine will love this machine.

2. Keurig K-Elite Single Serve Coffee Maker

If you're looking for a straightforward and reliable coffee maker without excessive features, the Keurig K-Elite Single Serve Coffee Maker is a great choice. There's a 75-ounce water reservoir, a drip tray, and a water filter, so it's both efficient and practical.

Modern kitchens will love this coffee maker because it takes up a minimal amount of counter space and looks great. Customers can choose from three stylish colors: brushed silver, gold, and slate. Its buttons are visible from a distance and illuminate when selected, giving a user-friendly experience despite not being clearly labeled.

Using the K-Elite is remarkably easy. Just insert your favorite coffee pod and press the designated buttons to select your drink size—4, 6, 8, 10, or 12 ounces. If you're using it for the first time, you might want to check the user manual for clarity because these sizes are only represented by pictures on the buttons.

One of the standout features of this machine is its quiet operation. It heats up and brews your coffee with minimal noise, so you can use it whenever. Furthermore, it's easy to clean only the water reservoir is removable and dishwasher safe.

The K-Elite's strong brew option makes it easy to customize your drink. The Keurig K-Elite Single Serve Coffee Maker makes a satisfying cup of coffee. It's a reliable, easy-to-use machine perfect for both casual drinkers and connoisseurs.

3. Keurig K-Duo Single Serve & Carafe Coffee Maker

The reviewer evaluated the Keurig K-Duo's performance and overall value over a two-week period. As a result, the K-Duo stands out among other models, like the K-Select, but remains compact enough for any kitchen countertop. Even though it's only available in black, black is a timeless and versatile color for kitchen appliances.

One of the standout features is the easy-to-use LCD screen and buttons that light up to provide clear indicators for brewing time, chosen ounces, and brew type. The K-Duo is designed for versatility; users can brew a full carafe or a single serving using K-Cup pods.

Pushing the handle down to puncture a K-Cup takes a little effort. Furthermore, features like the 'strong' button let you brew a stronger cup, and the 'pause and pour' option lets you dispense hot water before brewing.

K-Duo has an Auto-Off button, so you don't have to worry about overheating or forgetting to turn it off. Brewing takes just five minutes with ground coffee and a filter, and the warming plate keeps it hot for two hours—perfect for second cups. There's enough water in the reservoir to last several days without refilling.

Ultimately, the K-Duo is easy to clean and delivers a satisfying cup of coffee, so it's a great option for coffee lovers.

4. Keurig K-Supreme SMART Coffee Maker

The Keurig K-Supreme Smart Coffee Maker stands out from simpler ones. With this coffee maker, users can adjust the strength and temperature of the brew to suit their tastes. Plus it has a Wi-Fi connection, you can adjust coffee settings from the comfort of your couch.

In addition to having a dual-position water tank and raised screen, the K-Supreme is an ideal single-serve option for small kitchens. Its lightweight design makes it easy to transport, and it's user-friendly, thanks to a handle on the 66-ounce plastic water tank and an intuitive digital control panel.

On the K-Supreme, you can customize your cup with five different brew strengths and six different temperature settings. It also has an option for brewing coffee over ice and is compatible with K-Cups, so you can make it work for whatever you want.

While the coffee maker's performance impressed our reviewer, particularly its BrewID feature that optimizes settings for different drinks, the app left something to be desired. The app's functionality feels a little limited, and the reviewer says it's quicker to put a pod in and start the machine manually. Some features also require Wi-Fi, so make sure you have it connected.

5. Keurig K-Mini Plus

If you're short on space but still crave a good cup of coffee, the Keurig K-Mini Plus may be the perfect solution. It can be used in small living spaces, like apartments or dorm rooms. With only two brew settings, it takes a little while to make your coffee, but despite a few minor quirks, it makes a satisfying cup.

The Keurig K-Mini Plus fits perfectly into cramped kitchen spaces, making it a great space-saving option. The built-in container can store up to nine K-cups, but you might need more space for more pods.

This coffee maker's funky design makes it perfect for a dorm room or casual apartment. It's available in vibrant colors like misty green and cardinal red. The water tank is quite small and needs to be refilled for each cup even though it makes single servings of coffee instead of a full pot.

The handy 10-ounce line on the tank makes it easy to measure your water, and you can brew a stronger cup by pressing ‘strong.’

It takes about two minutes to heat up, but if you're in a hurry, it's a good choice. You should also use a tall mug to avoid splattering water on your counters, but the removable drip tray lets you use travel mugs.

Although the Keurig K-Mini Plus has its quirks, it's still a great coffee maker for small spaces since it brews hot, delicious coffee.

How to choose the best Keurig coffee maker for you

When buying a Keurig coffee maker, you'll want to consider price, of course, but there are also many other features you may want to think about, such as:

What type of coffee do you like to use? The Keurig coffee maker offers a wide range of options, from drip filter coffee to quick espresso-style coffee using pods. This variety will surely excite you, as there's a Keurig for every coffee preference.

Are you grinding those beans? The Keurig coffee maker with a built-in grinder for fresh coffee beans is not only a great idea for the real barista experience but can also save you money. This cost-saving potential will make you feel financially savvy.

Size is important! Machines with a carafe are great, as a larger coffee jug lets you share with family, in the office, with guests, etc. If you opt for a jug/carafe style, ensure you have a good heating plate, too, to make sure as little as possible goes to waste by getting cold. If you want coffee fast, you may want a smaller machine that heats up faster and gets you a single cup quickest.

Are you looking for other 'fancy' features? Some people want a regular coffee maker that'll pour out a nice hot espresso - simple as that. However, you may be looking for more advanced features, such as:

1. A timer - Some coffee makers have LED displays and digital clocks, so you can set a timer to start brewing your early morning coffee, ready for when you wake up. Who doesn't want a nice hot cup of joe waiting for them in the morning?

2. Auto-pause controls - so you don't have to wait for the machine to finish brewing to grab a coffee mid-brew.

3. Accessories for milky drinks - like a steam wand or milk frother for creating lattes and cappuccinos.

4. Strength controls—Some of the Keurigs listed above have a 'strong' button you can push when you need a stronger, darker cup.

5. Easy-clean features - very important if you're busy and don't have time to take apart your machine to clean it carefully.

6. Audible signals - have you ever made a coffee, forgotten about it, and found it stone-cold later? Some machines will beep so you can hear when your coffee is ready from the next room over.

As An Amazon Associate, We Earn Affiliate Commissions From Qualifying Purchases.