Understanding Labor Law 240 and 241 Liability Coverage for New York Contractors
New York contractors face unique challenges when it comes to insurance coverage due to the state’s strict Labor Laws 240 and 241. These laws, often referred to as the “Scaffold Law,” impose absolute liability on contractors and property owners for certain construction-related injuries. Without proper liability coverage, these laws can expose contractors to devastating financial risks.
What Are Labor Laws 240 and 241?
• Labor Law 240: Commonly known as the Scaffold Law, Labor Law 240 requires contractors and property owners to provide workers with proper safety equipment to prevent falls from heights. This law applies to activities such as erecting, demolishing, repairing, altering, painting, cleaning, or pointing a building or structure. If a worker falls or is struck by a falling object due to inadequate safety measures, the contractor or owner can be held strictly liable, regardless of the worker’s actions.
• Labor Law 241: This law imposes safety requirements on construction, excavation, and demolition sites to protect workers. It mandates compliance with specific safety standards set by the New York Industrial Code. Unlike Labor Law 240, liability under Labor Law 241 is not absolute; however, it still places a significant burden on contractors and property owners.
Why Is Labor Law Coverage a Problem Only in New York?
New York is the only state with laws as stringent as Labor Laws 240 and 241, where absolute liability applies, even if the worker’s negligence contributed to the accident. This unique legal landscape has driven up liability insurance costs for contractors, as insurance carriers face substantial risks in covering these claims.
The cost of liability insurance for New York contractors, especially those requiring Labor Law 240 and 241 coverage, has become exorbitant. In some cases, premiums have doubled or even tripled in recent years, forcing contractors to either absorb the cost or seek specialized brokers who understand the market.
Five Examples of Labor Law Claims
1. Worker Falls from a Scaffold: A painter falls from a poorly secured scaffold while working on the exterior of a building, resulting in severe injuries. The contractor is held liable under Labor Law 240.
2. Falling Object Injury: A construction worker is struck by a falling tool that wasn’t properly secured, leading to a head injury. The contractor is found liable due to inadequate safety measures.
3. Ladder Collapse: A roofer uses a defective ladder provided by the contractor, which collapses during use, causing multiple fractures. This triggers absolute liability under Labor Law 240.
4. Trench Cave-In: A worker is injured in a trench collapse due to insufficient shoring, violating Labor Law 241 safety regulations.
5. Unsecured Building Materials: A carpenter working at ground level is injured by a falling beam from an upper floor, leading to a claim under both Labor Law 240 and 241.
Recommended by LinkedIn
Three Claims Excluded Without Labor Law Coverage
1. Worker Falls from a Roof: A subcontractor’s employee falls from an unprotected roof edge. Without Labor Law coverage, the contractor’s general liability policy would exclude this claim.
2. Injury from Unsafe Scaffolding: A worker is seriously injured when a scaffold collapses due to improper assembly. Without the proper endorsement, this claim would not be covered.
3. Violation of Safety Standards: A contractor fails to provide adequate lighting on a construction site, resulting in a worker tripping and sustaining injuries. General liability policies without Labor Law coverage would exclude this claim.
Why Choose BGES Group?
Navigating New York’s complex construction insurance market requires expertise. BGES Group specializes in providing contractors with tailored insurance solutions, including liability policies that include Labor Law 240 and 241 coverage. With deep knowledge of the challenges New York contractors face, BGES Group ensures you have the protection you need at competitive rates.
Contact BGES Group
For expert assistance in obtaining Labor Law liability coverage, contact Gary Wallach at BGES Group:
• Phone: 914-806-5853
• Email: bgesgroup@gmail.com
* Website: www.bgesgroup.com
Don’t let New York’s Labor Laws put your business at risk. Call BGES Group today for comprehensive, cost-effective insurance solutions!