Understanding Risks in Business: Illustrated with Indian Example.

In the dynamic world of finance, understanding various types of risks is crucial for both investors and companies. Risk management forms the backbone of strategic planning, enabling businesses to navigate uncertainties and ensure long-term stability. Different types of risks, ranging from market fluctuations to operational failures, can significantly impact a company's performance and investor confidence. By examining real-world examples from prominent Indian companies, we can gain a deeper insight into how these risks manifest and the strategies employed to mitigate them. This newsletter delves into key risk categories, highlighting their implications with detailed case studies from India's corporate landscape.

Market Risk: The Volatility of Market Prices

Market risk, also known as systematic risk, refers to the potential for investors to experience losses due to factors that affect the overall performance of the financial markets. This includes fluctuations in stock prices, interest rates, exchange rates, and commodity prices. Companies in various sectors are susceptible to market risk, as their stock prices can be significantly influenced by macroeconomic trends, geopolitical events, and changes in market sentiment.

Example 1: Reliance Industries In 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic caused a global economic downturn, and Reliance Industries, one of India's largest conglomerates, was not immune to the impacts. The uncertainty surrounding the pandemic led to a sharp decline in market confidence. As a result, Reliance Industries' stock price fell from around ₹1,600 in February 2020 to ₹900 in March 2020. The significant drop in the company's stock price demonstrated how market risk can affect even the largest and most diversified firms.

Example 2: Tata Steel The steel industry is highly sensitive to global economic conditions. In 2018, the imposition of tariffs on steel imports by the United States led to volatility in global steel prices. Tata Steel, a major player in the Indian steel industry, saw its stock price fluctuate as a result of these international trade policies. The uncertainty and market reactions to such geopolitical events highlighted the exposure of companies like Tata Steel to market risk.

Credit Risk: The Threat of Default

Credit risk arises when a borrower fails to meet its financial obligations to the lender. This risk is particularly relevant for banks, financial institutions, and companies that extend credit to their customers. Credit risk can lead to significant financial losses and affect the stability of the financial system.

Example 1: DHFL (Dewan Housing Finance Corporation Limited) In 2019, DHFL, a major player in India's housing finance sector, defaulted on its debt payments. The company faced severe liquidity issues due to poor asset quality and aggressive lending practices. This default triggered a crisis in the non-banking financial company (NBFC) sector, causing widespread panic among investors and lenders. The DHFL case underscored the importance of stringent credit risk assessment and the need for maintaining healthy financial practices to avoid such defaults.

Example 2: Yes Bank Yes Bank, once one of India’s fastest-growing private sector banks, faced severe credit risk issues in 2020. The bank had extended significant loans to companies that eventually defaulted. The accumulation of bad loans strained Yes Bank’s financial health, leading to a crisis where it was unable to raise necessary capital. The Reserve Bank of India had to intervene, placing the bank under a moratorium and orchestrating a rescue plan involving other financial institutions.

Liquidity Risk: The Need for Ready Cash

Liquidity risk is the risk that a company will not be able to meet its short-term financial obligations due to an inability to quickly convert assets into cash without a significant loss in value. Companies with high liquidity risk may face operational challenges and could potentially default on their obligations.

Example 1: Jet Airways Jet Airways, once one of India’s leading airlines, faced a severe liquidity crisis in 2019. The airline struggled to manage its debt and operational costs, leading to a cash crunch. This inability to pay salaries, suppliers, and lessors ultimately grounded its fleet and halted operations. The Jet Airways crisis highlighted the critical importance of maintaining liquidity to ensure business continuity.

Example 2: IL&FS The IL&FS crisis also exemplified liquidity risk. As the company defaulted on several debt repayments, it faced a severe cash flow shortage. This inability to service its short-term liabilities despite having long-term assets demonstrated how a liquidity mismatch can escalate into a full-blown crisis.

Operational Risk: Failures in Processes and Systems

Operational risk arises from the failure of internal processes, people, systems, or from external events. This can include fraud, system failures, human errors, or natural disasters. Effective risk management practices are essential to mitigate operational risks and ensure the smooth functioning of business operations.

Example 1: Punjab National Bank (PNB) In 2018, PNB uncovered a significant fraud involving unauthorized transactions worth over ₹13,000 crore. Employees at one of the bank’s branches issued fraudulent letters of undertaking without proper authorization. This operational lapse led to substantial financial losses and highlighted weaknesses in the bank’s internal controls and risk management systems.

Example 2: Infosys In 2019, Infosys faced allegations of unethical practices and financial irregularities by whistleblowers. These allegations caused a sharp decline in the company’s stock price and raised concerns about its internal governance and operational controls. Although Infosys conducted an internal investigation and found no evidence of wrongdoing, the incident underscored the importance of robust operational risk management.

Legal and Regulatory Risk: Navigating Legal Changes

Legal and regulatory risk refers to the risk of financial loss due to changes in laws, regulations, or from legal actions. Companies operating in highly regulated industries must stay abreast of regulatory changes to ensure compliance and avoid legal penalties.

Example 1: Vodafone Idea Vodafone Idea, one of India’s largest telecom operators, faced significant legal and regulatory challenges due to a Supreme Court ruling on adjusted gross revenue (AGR) dues. The court ordered telecom companies to pay billions in dues, leading to a massive financial burden on Vodafone Idea. The regulatory risk associated with such legal rulings posed a threat to the company’s survival and highlighted the impact of regulatory changes on business operations.

Example 2: Cairn Energy vs. Government of India In 2020, Cairn Energy won an arbitration case against the Indian government over a retrospective tax demand. The ruling ordered the Indian government to pay damages to Cairn Energy. This case underscored the legal and regulatory risks foreign companies face in India, especially concerning retrospective tax legislation.

Reputational Risk: The Impact on Trust

Reputational risk is the risk of loss resulting from damage to a company's reputation. Negative publicity, scandals, or customer dissatisfaction can lead to a loss of trust and confidence, impacting a company's financial performance and market position.

Example 1: Maggi Noodles (Nestlé India) In 2015, Nestlé India’s popular product, Maggi noodles, faced a ban after the food safety regulator found high levels of lead in some samples. The incident led to a nationwide recall and a temporary halt in sales. The controversy severely damaged Nestlé India’s reputation and resulted in financial losses. It took significant effort and time for the company to restore consumer trust and regain its market position.

Example 2: Satyam Computer Services In 2009, Satyam Computer Services was involved in a major accounting scandal where the company's founder admitted to falsifying accounts. This led to a loss of credibility and trust among investors, clients, and employees. The scandal resulted in significant financial and reputational damage, ultimately leading to the company’s takeover by Tech Mahindra.

Systemic Risk: The Ripple Effect

Systemic risk is the risk of collapse of an entire financial system or market, often triggered by the failure of a significant financial institution or a group of institutions. This type of risk can lead to widespread economic disruption.

Example 1: Banking Sector Crisis Post-Demonetization In 2016, the Indian government’s decision to demonetize ₹500 and ₹1,000 currency notes led to a temporary systemic risk in the banking sector. The sudden influx of deposits and the subsequent cash shortages created operational challenges for banks. The demonetization move affected the entire financial system, particularly small businesses and rural areas reliant on cash transactions, illustrating how a significant policy change can lead to systemic risk.

Example 2: Infrastructure Leasing & Financial Services (IL&FS) The IL&FS default in 2018 posed a systemic risk to the Indian financial system. The company's default led to a liquidity crisis affecting various sectors, including mutual funds, NBFCs, and banks. The widespread impact of IL&FS’s financial troubles demonstrated how the failure of a large institution can ripple through the entire financial system.

Country Risk: Challenges of the Operating Environment

Country risk refers to the risk of investing in a country due to changes in its economic, political, or social environment. This includes political instability, changes in government policies, and economic downturns that can affect the business environment.

Example 1: Vodafone India Vodafone faced significant country risk due to regulatory and tax issues in India. The company was involved in a prolonged legal battle over retrospective taxation, which demanded billions in back taxes. This created an uncertain business environment, affecting Vodafone’s financial stability and highlighting the challenges of operating in a complex regulatory landscape.

Example 2: Kingfisher Airlines Kingfisher Airlines, owned by Vijay Mallya, faced severe financial difficulties leading to its shutdown in 2012. High operating costs, tax policies, and regulatory challenges in India contributed to the airline’s financial woes. The failure of Kingfisher Airlines underscored the country risk associated with operating in a challenging and dynamic regulatory environment.

Exchange Rate Risk: Currency Fluctuations

Exchange rate risk, also known as currency risk, arises from changes in the value of one currency relative to another. Companies engaged in international trade or with significant foreign operations are particularly exposed to exchange rate risk.

Example 1: Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) As a major exporter of IT services, TCS earns a significant portion of its revenue in US dollars. When the Indian Rupee appreciates against the US Dollar, the company’s revenue and profit margins can be negatively impacted. To mitigate this risk, TCS employs hedging strategies to protect against unfavorable currency movements.

Example 2: Infosys Infosys, another leading IT services exporter, also faces exchange rate risk due to its global operations. Fluctuations in currency values can affect its profitability and financial performance. Like TCS, Infosys uses hedging instruments to manage exchange rate risk and stabilize its earnings.

In conclusion, the multifaceted nature of risk underscores the importance of comprehensive risk management practices. As illustrated by the experiences of Indian companies such as Reliance Industries, Yes Bank, and Tata Consultancy Services, understanding and mitigating various types of risks is essential for sustaining growth and protecting stakeholder value. By learning from these examples, businesses can better prepare for uncertainties and investors can make more informed decisions. The continuous evaluation of risks and the implementation of robust mitigation strategies will remain pivotal in navigating the ever-evolving financial environment. Embracing these practices not only enhances resilience but also paves the way for sustainable success in the competitive market landscape.

Will learn about managing this risk soon. So, do follow Prajjawal Verma

Also you can check a summary post on this here: Click