Unlock ways to maximize Consulting Value w/ Insights for Clients and Consultants

Consulting services often face criticism for being expensive, while clients remain skeptical about the value they receive. But there’s more to consulting than just its price tag. Here’s how both sides—clients and consultants—can get the most out of their partnerships by focusing on value, transparency, and collaboration.

1. The Real Story Behind Consulting Fees

Consulting fees aren’t arbitrary—they’re built on specific factors like daily rates, project scope, and expertise. It’s not uncommon for clients to raise eyebrows at the costs, but breaking it down shows the true picture. For instance, a fee might reflect a combination of expert know-how, industry insights, visual design services (for the creation of slides) and proprietary tools that a consulting firm brings to the table. Simply put, you get what you pay for. Consultants are not just execution units you deploy - they come along with deep expertise and knowledge about how to approach different types of situations to solve problems.

Clients often ask, “Why so expensive?” It’s not just about time spent; it’s about the value the consultancy brings—whether it’s specialized solutions, innovative methodologies, or just the ability to see things that in-house teams may overlook. Clients that focus on value, not just costs, when evaluating proposals end up with better project outcomes. And value goes beyond just hiring the cheapest person for the job.

2. The Consulting Pyramid: How It Works

Many consulting firms operate with a pyramid structure, where the bulk of the work is done by consultants, while Managers and Partners focus on strategy, oversight, and client relationships. This structure isn’t just about hierarchy—it’s about efficiency. However, clients should understand that the real workhorses—the consultants—are the ones who drive much of the project’s progress.

Here’s where clients sometimes miss the mark: they equate price with the seniority of team members. But a well-managed consulting project relies on the strength of the entire team, not just its leaders. The balance between experienced leadership and hands-on execution is where great outcomes are born.

3. The Value of Transparency in Consulting

Trust is the bedrock of any successful consulting project. That’s why transparency from day one is crucial. Clients need to know where their money is going, and consultants must be clear about how they allocate time and resources.

One common pitfall? Failing to define success metrics upfront. Both sides should work together to clearly define the desired outcome—whether it’s cost savings, operational improvements, or strategic insights. Without this, even the best consultancy can miss the mark, leaving the client unsatisfied despite good work.

4. The Rise of In-House Consulting: A Real Threat?

Companies are increasingly creating in-house consulting teams, believing that they can cut costs and increase control over project outcomes. While this might seem like a great idea on paper, external consultancies bring a different set of advantages. They offer a fresh perspective, specialized expertise, and a broader market view—something an internal team, no matter how skilled, may lack.

In-house teams can be great for execution, but when it comes to strategy and transformation, external consultants are invaluable. They aren’t bogged down by company politics or blind spots—making them more effective in driving substantial change.

5. Fostering a Collaborative Partnership

The best consulting projects happen when both parties are fully invested. For clients, that means being clear about their goals and expectations from the outset. For consultants, it’s about listening to the client’s needs and not just delivering a templated solution.

Collaboration is the secret sauce. When clients treat consultants as trusted advisors rather than just service providers, they unlock the real value of consulting. By working hand in hand, they can achieve long-lasting results that benefit the business far beyond the life of the project.

6. When to Hire Freelancers from Leading Firms

There are instances where hiring freelance consultants—especially alumni from top firms like McKinsey or BCG—can be more advantageous than engaging a full consulting team. These individuals often possess the same high-caliber expertise as their former firms but offer greater flexibility and a more hands-on approach. Freelancers can be ideal for projects requiring specific, targeted insights rather than large-scale, team-based efforts. While their day rates may be higher than the average freelancer due to their experience and reputation, they typically deliver more focused, tailored solutions, and the absence of a larger team can significantly reduce overhead costs. This approach works well when you need top-tier expertise without the full cost structure of a major consulting engagement.

How to find the best consultant for the job

When you’re evaluating whether a consultant is the right fit for your project, you don’t always have the luxury of time for deep analysis. But there are a few key things you can focus on quickly. First, it’s important to look at whether they’ve dealt with similar challenges in your industry—past experience is often a great indicator of whether they’ll deliver what you need. Don't hesitate to ask for real examples of how their work has made a measurable impact elsewhere; consultants who can point to specific results tend to bring the most value.

You’ll also want to gauge if their skills match the specific needs of your project. If you need someone with deep technical knowledge or strategic insight, make sure they’re not just generalists but have proven expertise in those areas. Another factor that’s often overlooked is how well they’ll fit with your team—cultural alignment can make or break a project, no matter how skilled the consultant is. Lastly, a good consultant should have a clear and practical approach that aligns with your timeline and objectives, not just theories.

It’s also worth remembering that a consultant’s day rate often covers more than just their hours. Much of their value comes from the work they do behind the scenes—preparing, researching, and customizing their approach to your specific business challenges. You’re also paying for their hard-earned expertise and access to specialized tools or methodologies that they’ve refined over time. On top of that, many consultants offer ongoing support after the project ends, ensuring you continue to benefit from their insights. And if they’re well-connected in your industry, their network could open doors or provide additional value that goes beyond the scope of the initial engagement.

Need help to staff your next consulting project with Alumni from leading management consulting firms incl. MBB?

Reach out to us at Scipio & Partners - one of Europe's leading networks of freelancing consulting professionals from leading strategy consulting firms. We don't ask for commissions to staff your team.

www.scipio.expert

contact@scipio.expert