The Unseen Cost of Treating Humans as Line Items

The Unseen Cost of Treating Humans as Line Items

There’s a certain type of leader who sees people as disposable. They don’t say it outright; they hide behind words like “efficiency” and “optimisation.” But make no mistake—laying off tens of thousands of employees as if they’re line items on a balance sheet is not leadership. It’s moral bankruptcy disguised as strategy.

These decisions ripple far beyond the spreadsheet. Every name crossed off is a parent explaining to their family why the mortgage might not get paid. It’s a community losing its economic backbone. It’s a team left demoralised, wondering if they’re next. And it doesn’t stop there—customers feel the strain in weakened service, partners lose trust, and the very culture that made success possible begins to rot.

Real leaders don’t slash jobs for short-term stock bumps or to protect bloated bonuses. They ask: “How did we get here?” They hold themselves accountable, not just their teams. They look for every alternative before cutting people loose. Because they know the truth: when you treat people as disposable, your leadership becomes disposable, too.

The question is: will you lead in a way that strengthens your legacy—or lets it crumble under the weight of your short-term thinking?


Thriving in Challenging Times: A Blueprint for Values-Driven Leadership

Leadership isn’t about surviving today’s turbulence; it’s about thriving tomorrow. It’s not about short-term optics but long-term impact. True leadership demands more than competence or charisma—it requires fostering trust, clarity, and resilience in every decision you make.

The leaders we need rise above transactional thinking. They lean into complexity, build cultures rooted in empathy and accountability, and make decisions that reinforce the trust of employees, customers, and communities.

Here’s how real leaders not only survive but thrive:


1. Lead with Radical Transparency

Why It Matters:

Trust is earned in moments of truth. In a world of growing scepticism, transparency isn’t just good PR—it’s the foundation of credibility. Leaders who share the why behind their decisions foster understanding, even in the face of tough realities.

What This Looks Like:

  • Explain Decisions: When Unilever restructured globally, they communicated not just the “what” but the “why,” connecting decisions to their sustainability strategy and long-term goals.
  • Own Mistakes: Alan Mulally’s turnaround at Ford started with admitting failures and embracing solutions from every level of the organisation.
  • Demystify the Process: Instead of opaque, top-down decisions, involve teams in understanding the principles driving actions. When decisions feel inclusive, trust thrives.

Are you being transparent to build trust—or holding back to protect your comfort zone?

2. Embrace Empathy Without Compromising Accountability

Why It Matters:

Empathy builds bridges; accountability builds progress. Great leaders integrate both, creating teams that feel valued while achieving their best. Without this balance, cultures fracture under fear or complacency.

What This Looks Like:

  • Active Listening: Howard Schultz, during Starbucks’ turnaround, sought direct feedback from employees at every level, blending compassion with tough operational decisions.
  • Clear Expectations: Patagonia’s environmental mission holds employees accountable to the company’s higher purpose, showing that empathy can align with performance.
  • Constructive Feedback: Deliver feedback as a tool for growth, not punishment. Conversations rooted in care inspire commitment to improvement.

Is your empathy driving connection or enabling avoidance? Is your accountability inspiring growth or fuelling fear?

3. Build Cultures of Psychological Safety

Why It Matters:

Innovation requires risk, and risk requires safety. Cultures where employees fear speaking up become stagnant. Thriving leaders build environments where voices are valued, ideas are explored, and mistakes are treated as learning opportunities.

What This Looks Like:

  • Encourage Dissent: At Pixar, every team member is empowered to challenge ideas, ensuring the best outcomes emerge from debate.
  • Celebrate Learning: Google’s Project Aristotle proved that teams thrive when they’re allowed to fail forward—learning from setbacks rather than hiding them.
  • Reinforce Inclusion: Diverse perspectives make decisions smarter. Inclusive forums ensure no voice goes unheard.

Do your actions make it safe for others to tell you the truth, even when it’s uncomfortable?

4. Adapt Without Betraying Your Core Values

Why It Matters:

Flexibility without principle is chaos. Thriving leaders adapt to change but remain steadfast in their values, ensuring their decisions align with their organisation’s deeper purpose.

What This Looks Like:

  • Anchor in Values: When Ben & Jerry’s expanded globally, they refused to compromise on their social justice commitments, proving growth doesn’t mean abandoning principles.
  • Scenario Planning: Plan for multiple outcomes to pivot with agility while staying aligned with long-term goals.
  • Decisive Action: Once you’ve evaluated options, commit with confidence and communicate clearly to ensure alignment.

When adapting to challenges, are you strengthening your mission, or diluting it?

5. Cultivate Emotional Resilience

Why It Matters:

Your emotional state as a leader sets the tone for your organisation. If you’re reactive or ungrounded, your team will reflect that chaos. Emotional resilience enables clarity under pressure and inspires confidence in others.

What This Looks Like:

  • Practice Self-Awareness: Journaling or mindfulness exercises can help process stress and clarify thinking during uncertainty.
  • Model Balance: Burnout at the top trickles down. Prioritising well-being signals that sustainable success matters more than short-term hustle.
  • Lead with Presence: In moments of crisis, stay fully engaged. Your calm, focused energy creates stability.

When pressure peaks, how do you ensure your emotions serve your leadership rather than sabotage it?

6. Shift from Control to Empowerment

Why It Matters:

Command-and-control leadership stifles innovation and engagement. Thriving leaders delegate authority and trust their teams to take ownership, fostering autonomy and accountability.

What This Looks Like:

  • Delegate Decisions: Netflix’s culture empowers teams to operate independently within clear parameters, creating a high-performance environment.
  • Celebrate Collective Wins: Recognising team achievements builds unity and reinforces shared purpose.
  • Teach Problem-Solving: Equip teams with frameworks to make informed decisions, even under uncertainty.

Are you empowering future leaders—or perpetuating dependence on your control?

Is Your Legacy, Leadership?

Leadership is measured not by the headlines you grab but by the trust you build and the legacy you leave.

When your team, your customers, and your communities look back, will they see a leader who put people first, or one who treated them as line items? Pawns in their accumulation of wealth at any cost?

The truth is simple: when you treat people as disposable, your leadership becomes disposable, too.

The choice is yours. Make it count.

Prashant Vaid

Hotel Manager @ Leonardo Hotels UK & Ireland | Hospitality Management

4w

“Efficiency seekers” … love this. The short term ninjas. Very thoughtful article. Thank you.

Matt McDarby

President @ United Sales Resources | Sales Leader | Creator of the Sales Leaders Operating System™️

4w

The types of leaders you are describing, Marcus Cauchi, are also the ones who don’t give sufficient consideration to what it takes for people to be successful in their roles. They don’t invest time, thought or resources into communicating clear expectations, developing proper job descriptions and success profiles, or development plans beyond basic on-boarding. I’ve unfortunately seen it so many times that it is easy to spot the signs of an organization that is setting people up to fail.

Like
Reply
Mark Herbert

Managing Principal New Paradigms LLC

4w

Great article Marcus! I have always despised the expression "human capital" and what it implies. We don't employ human capital we employ people. The data has clearly demonstrated the trillions of dollars that the international economy has bled out due to continuing employee disengagement and we are also seeing trust in the traditional institutions erode year by year. I would submit these costs are only "unseen" if you have your head in the sand or in a place that is anatomically impossible. Appreciating people and understanding and employing the skills of leadership as opposed to management is not "soft". in the US we once again reelected a President who values personal loyalty above competence or integrity because we think he will be better at protecting the economy. I hope we are prepared for the long term consequences of that decision...

Aaron H.

Top Voice in Brand Development | Chief Marketer @ AH Marketing | Your B2B Fractional Marketing Team | We ❤️ Marketing Challenges

1mo

It’s difficult to serve in the leadership position. I appreciate how you laid out the essentials here. As they say, teams / organizations / countries rise and fall on leadership.

Samantha Wall 🐝🐝

Digital Marketing Strategist- MCIM / Business & Student Mentor / Social Entrepreneur

1mo

I couldn’t agree more, in larger companies Ive seen it in the past, people treated as a cost on a spreadsheet & not as a person (by the business). I used to work at BAE Systems years back, there were mass redundancies at Woodford’s site as they were discontinuing Nimrod MRA4 which had replaced the HS801 MR2. I worked in logistics on the passenger craft side - it didn’t directly effect my role but had to bare witness to 100s of engineers being laid off one after the other for weeks on end. It deeply affected all of us, most were men with families to support, it had a ripple effect around the entire business, I would say everyone working there was emotionally impacted in some way. It was one of the most difficult periods & I directly reported to the person tasked to do the hiring/firing. He was a decent man (but v disliked due to his role in the redundancies), no one saw the emotional impact it had on him-except me-one morning I was in the office, I didn’t think he was in & I had to leave paperwork on his desk before a meeting, lights were off, so I pushed the door open & found him sobbing at his desk, it made me cry too, he confided in me a lot, I knew he saw these people as human beings but felt he had to contain his emotions.

To view or add a comment, sign in

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics