What Broadening Market Performance Means for Investors

The stock market has continued its historic rally with the S&P 500 gaining 19% year-to-date with reinvested dividends, contributing to a total return of 61% since the market bottom in 2022.

While much of this performance has been driven by large cap technology stocks over the past 18 months, there are now signs that other parts of the market are benefiting as well.

While investors tend to focus on major market indices and the one or two areas driving recent returns, the reality is that performance leadership tends to change over time. Large cap tech stocks have dominated headlines recently and for good reason – the Magnificent Seven stocks have gained 192% over the past year and a half. This is partly due to excitement over artificial intelligence breakthroughs, and partly because lower interest rates are generally positive for growth. This recent performance is also a reversal of the tech crash in 2022 when the Fed hiked rates.

However, as the accompanying chart shows, there are now signs that other areas of the market are beginning to participate.

Performance is broadening beyond large cap growth

Recent economic reports indicate inflation is cooling, which many expect will have the Fed cutting rates sometime this year. This expectation has started to drive the performance of both small cap stocks and large cap value stocks.

Small cap stocks in particular tend to be more sensitive to interest rates since they represent less mature companies that often have more limited access to capital. Thus, the prospect of lower rates can be a catalyst for many of these stocks. These companies also tend to be more U.S.-focused, so they often outperform when there is positive news on economic growth.

Growth and value can each outperform over long periods

Value stocks have also performed better recently due to these same factors. Notably, this has not been at the expense of growth stocks, per se. Instead, value stocks may be in the early stages of catching up after lagging for the past 18 months.

What exactly are value and growth stocks? While their exact definitions can differ among investors, these factors tend to be characterized by each stock’s valuation level. Those with lower valuations tend to be characterized as “value” while those with higher valuations are classified as “growth.” More broadly, value investors hope that a stock’s share price will adjust based on what it “should” be worth based on fundamentals such as earnings. Growth investors, on the other hand, hope that a company will continue to grow substantially, and are thus less concerned about the current valuation level or share price. 

The chart above provides historical perspective on how value and growth have fluctuated over time. In the late 1990s and early 2000s, growth stocks outperformed during the dot-com boom. This then gave way to strong outperformance of value stocks through much of the 2000s. This cyclical rotation from growth to value and back has occurred throughout history, driving much of the academic research around the so-called “value premium.” So, while growth stocks have strongly outperformed most recently, history shows that leadership changes are not unusual.

Diversifying across styles helps to reduce portfolio risk

The recent outperformance of growth stocks does not mean that diversification is no longer relevant. In fact, the opposite is true: diversifying across styles allows investors to benefit from recent market trends while also protecting their portfolios from potential risks.

The chart above shows that those parts of the market that have performed well also have the highest relative valuations. The price-to-earnings ratio of large cap growth is now 28.4, driving the overall S&P 500 index P/E to 21.2. In contrast, large cap value only has a P/E of 15.7 while small cap value is far less expensive at 13.8. This is the case even though small cap value stocks are expected to experience earnings growth rates similar to large cap growth stocks over the next twelve months.

Performance has broadened across sectors as well. Ten of the eleven S&P 500 sectors have positive returns this year, with only the real estate sector slightly negative. Many sectors have year-to-date gains of 8% or more including financials, utilities, consumer discretionary, industrials, consumer staples, healthcare, and energy. While tech stocks have received most of the attention, and a few individual stocks have significantly outperformed the market, there are signs that other sectors are benefiting from the rally as well.

The bottom line? History shows that long-term investing isn’t just about “predicting winners” – it’s also about diversifying across styles, sectors, and more. Market leadership not only changes over time but also can do so swiftly. Staying diversified allows long-term investors to benefit from opportunities while also having a smoother ride as they work toward their financial goals.

Timothy Corriero (represented under the trade name of Juris Wealth) is an Investment Advisor Representative of Gemmer Asset Management LLC ("GAM"), an investment adviser registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission that maintains its principal place of business located in Walnut Creek, California. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Mr. Corriero provides investment advisory services in his individual capacity as an Investment Advisor Representative of GAM. Juris Wealth is not a registered investment adviser and does not provide investment advisory services. The views expressed above are those of Tim Corriero and do not necessarily reflect those of GAM. Investing in stock markets involves the risk of loss. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Information presented herein (including all charts, graphs, and statistics) is believed to be factual and up to date, but we do not guarantee its accuracy and it should not be regarded as a complete analysis of the subjects discussed. Information in these materials may change at any time and without notice. All investing involves risk. Past performance is not a guarantee or indicative of future returns. This material is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on for, tax, legal or accounting advice. You should consult your own tax, legal and accounting professionals before engaging in any transaction. Any mention of a specific law firm herein does not constitute an endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by such firm.