When Winning Isn’t Everything: What Election Season Can Teach Us About Leadership

The election environment can turn up the heat in any workplace. But when beliefs clash, does your team get stronger—or start to crack? Election season can bring out potent feelings for all of us. No matter which side you’re on, avoiding the emotional highs and lows is almost impossible when the results come in. And when these reactions appear in the workplace, it’s a test of our character and leadership.

So, how do we handle those moments when working with someone whose beliefs don’t match ours? Do we lean into empathy or let the differences build walls between us?

The Story of a Team with Different Perspectives on the Election

Take Sarah, a marketing manager, and her boss, Tom, the VP of Sales. Tom and Sarah have always respected each other but come from different backgrounds and political views. As the election approached, those differences became more challenging to ignore, and both felt the weight of what was at stake.

Then, the results came in. Tom’s candidate won, and Sarah’s candidate lost. The office was a mix of celebration and disappointment. At that moment, Tom and Sarah faced a choice: let their differences create a rift or rise above it.

A Lesson in Sportsmanship: Winning with Grace, Losing with Dignity

Here’s what happened. Feeling the satisfaction of a win, Tom could have easily celebrated and voiced his opinions publicly. But he chose a different path. He approached Sarah privately and acknowledged that this was an emotional moment for both of them. He let her know that he valued her commitment to her beliefs and appreciated the hard work she continued to put into their shared goals.

Sarah, though disappointed, recognized this as a chance to practice resilience. She thanked Tom for his respect and reminded herself that a single election outcome didn’t define her worth or her role on the team. Instead of dwelling on the loss, she refocused on the projects they cared about and leaned into the work that united them.

The Real Test of Leadership: How Do You React When You “Win” or “Lose”?

Tom and Sarah’s story reminds us of something powerful: True character shows in how we carry ourselves afterward, in both victory and defeat. Winning with grace means resisting the urge to gloat, and losing with dignity means refusing to let one moment define our spirit.

This is especially important in the workplace. We all have different beliefs, but if we let those differences divide us, we miss the opportunity to build something stronger together. Think of it like sportsmanship—there’s power in humility after a win, and there’s resilience in showing up after a loss.

Practical Strategies for Leaders Navigating High-Stakes Moments

When emotions run high, it’s up to leaders to set the tone. Here are three ways you can handle these situations and keep your team united, even during divisive times like election season:

1. Acknowledge Emotions, But Stay Focused on the Mission

During heated times, remind your team that the bigger picture—your mission—is what unites you. Encourage everyone to respect each other’s feelings, but keep the focus on your shared goals. This can help balance euphoria with humility and disappointment with resilience. Collective success is about more than one win or loss; it’s about the team's strength.

2. Create Space for Empathy and Dialogue

Sometimes, people just need to be heard. If your team members feel strongly about an outcome, give them space to express themselves, but set the tone for respectful dialogue. Tom’s choice to speak privately with Sarah allowed them to move forward without tension. Empathy doesn’t mean you have to agree—it means you’re willing to listen.

3. Model Grace Under Pressure

Your team watches how you respond to both wins and losses. You're setting the example when you show grace in victory and resilience in defeat. Each outcome, whether positive or negative, is an opportunity to learn. When leaders embrace this mindset, it fosters a culture where people feel safe, valued, and motivated to keep improving.

The Takeaway: Embracing Differences Without Letting Them Divide Us

Tom and Sarah’s story reminds us that political differences don’t have to be a source of division. Instead, they can be a chance to practice empathy, resilience, and respect—qualities that strengthen any team. Studies even back this up: Companies with inclusive workplace cultures are twice as likely to meet or exceed their financial targets and six times more likely to be innovative and agile. A respectful, resilient team isn’t just good for morale; it’s a strategic advantage.

Leaders set the tone in times of emotional highs and lows. When you lead with integrity, encouraging your team to embody sportsmanship in victory and defeat, you create an environment where everyone feels valued and aligned with a common purpose.

Creating a Culture of Respect and Resilience

Building a workplace where people feel respected and united isn’t about pushing emotions aside or pretending differences don’t exist. It’s about approaching those differences humbly and committed to shared values. When team members from different backgrounds and perspectives feel heard, their unique insights can drive innovation and help solve complex problems in ways a homogeneous team might miss.

As we move forward, let’s aim to foster a workplace culture where winning isn’t about one side prevailing over another but about everyone rising together. Let’s shape a space where we celebrate shared goals, acknowledge each other’s journeys, and ultimately, learn to embrace differences as strengths.

So, here’s the question: How will you lead when your team is divided? Will you build walls, or will you build bridges?

If you’re ready to build a culture that respects differences and fosters resilience, let’s connect. Let's work together to create a team culture that values resilience and respect, where we define success not by winning or losing but by the integrity we bring to every challenge.

What's next?

Kickstart your journey to lasting change with a FREE summary of James Clear's bestselling book Atomic Habits. Discover how small, consistent steps can lead to extraordinary results. This summary distills the key insights and provides practical action steps to help you immediately start transforming your habits and achieving your goals.

But that’s not all!

Along with the free guide, you’ll receive a specially curated AI ChatGPT tool to help you apply the concepts from "Atomic Habits" to your biggest goals and challenges.

Looking forward to hearing your thoughts!

Click here to download your FREE Atomic Habits summary and start your transformation today!