Are You Hiring or Testing? Rethinking Take-Home Assignments in the Hiring Process!
CareerXperts Consulting
We Connect you with the "Right People", Companies, and Best Practices to Help You Thrive and Grow. Hiring for Startups!
Take-Home Assignments in Hiring: A Fresh Perspective
Imagine this: You’re leading a fast-growing startup or managing a critical team at a well-established organization. Every minute of your team’s time is accounted for, directed toward building, innovating, and delivering. Now consider this - how would you feel if one of your team members was asked to dedicate several hours to solving a hypothetical problem for another company? Sounds absurd, doesn’t it?
Yet, this is exactly what many companies expect candidates to do during the hiring process. Lengthy take-home assignments have become a common practice, especially for technical roles. While the intent may be to evaluate a candidate’s skills and fit, it’s worth asking - are these assignments a reflection of your company’s problem-solving culture, or are they simply an outdated checkbox in your hiring process?
Let’s explore how companies can rethink and reshape take-home assignments to make them meaningful, efficient, and respectful of everyone’s time and effort.
Take-Home Assignments: A Double-Edged Sword
"Time is the scarcest resource, and unless it is managed, nothing else can be managed." – Peter Drucker
Take-home assignments, at their core, aim to simulate real-world tasks and give candidates the chance to showcase their skills. On paper, it sounds reasonable. But the challenge arises when these assignments become overly time-consuming or detached from the role they’re meant to evaluate.
For candidates, especially those already working full-time, a lengthy take-home test can feel like a daunting burden. Many are juggling professional commitments, personal responsibilities, and often multiple interview processes. A long, unpaid task can leave candidates questioning - does this company value efficiency, or is this a preview of an unnecessarily bureaucratic work culture?
On the company’s side, a poorly designed or overly demanding assignment risks alienating strong candidates. And let’s not overlook the message it sends - how you structure your hiring process reflects how you operate as an organization.
Reimagining Take-Home Assignments
How do we fix this? How can companies create assignments that are effective for evaluation yet considerate of a candidate’s time and circumstances?
1. Ask Yourself: What Are We Really Testing?
"Judge a man by his questions rather than by his answers." – Voltaire
Before designing any take-home assignment, reflect on what you truly need to evaluate. Are you testing for technical proficiency, problem-solving ability, or creativity? Or is it just a habit to hand out lengthy tasks?
If the goal is technical evaluation, why not consider a live coding session or a collaborative problem-solving exercise? If it’s creativity, why not ask for insights into how they’ve solved similar problems in the past? Tailoring the evaluation to the role will save everyone time and energy.
2. Keep Assignments Relevant and Realistic
A bold question to consider: Would you ask your current team to spend hours on a task without compensation or context? If not, then why ask it of someone you’re trying to hire?
The best take-home assignments simulate challenges your team is currently tackling. Candidates appreciate when they see the practical application of their effort. It also gives them a glimpse into the kind of work they’ll be doing if they join your organization.
By tying the assignment to a real scenario, you not only evaluate skills but also engage the candidate in your company’s mission.
3. Time Is Precious - Respect It
Assignments should be designed to take a reasonable amount of time, and companies should clearly communicate the expected effort upfront. A good rule of thumb? If the task takes more than a few hours, it’s time to rethink.
If your assignment is more involved, consider breaking it into smaller, manageable segments. Or better yet, ask candidates to tackle part of the task during a collaborative interview session.
4. Make Feedback Non-Negotiable
"The deepest principle in human nature is the craving to be appreciated." – William James
When candidates invest their time in your hiring process, the least you can do is provide them with thoughtful, actionable feedback. Whether you move forward with them or not, this gesture demonstrates respect and shows that your company values effort.
It’s not just about goodwill - candidates who leave with a positive impression are more likely to recommend your company to others.
5. Compensation Signals Professionalism
Here’s a bold idea: Why not pay candidates for their time?
While not yet a widespread practice, compensating candidates for extensive assignments sets your company apart. Even a small token of appreciation signals that you respect their effort and time.
This approach also helps ensure that the candidates who take on the task are genuinely interested in the role, creating a win-win situation.
A Shift in Perspective: Collaboration Over Testing
What if the hiring process felt less like an exam and more like a collaboration? Instead of lengthy take-home assignments, consider interactive alternatives:
These alternatives reduce the time burden while providing deeper insights into a candidate’s thought process and fit for your team.
Why It Matters: Beyond the Assignment
"Culture eats strategy for breakfast." – Peter Drucker
A lengthy or impersonal hiring process can deter the very candidates you’re trying to attract. Talented individuals often have multiple options, and how you structure your hiring process sends a strong signal about your company’s culture and values.
By rethinking take-home assignments, you’re not just improving the candidate experience - you’re strengthening your employer brand. Candidates who feel respected and engaged are more likely to recommend your company to others, even if they don’t join.
Here’s a question to ponder: If your hiring process were a reflection of your workplace culture, would it attract the people you want to work with?
A Final Thought
Hiring is about more than just evaluation - it’s about inspiration. It’s about making candidates feel excited to work with you.
So, before you send out another long take-home assignment, take a moment to ask yourself: Is this truly the best way to find the talent we need?
The hiring process should be a two-way street. Respect for time, clear communication, and meaningful engagement aren’t just good practices - they’re foundational to building a team that’s excited to grow with you. After all, great hiring isn’t just about finding the right fit - it’s about creating the right impression.
"People may forget what you said, but they will never forget how you made them feel." – Maya Angelou
Ready to elevate your hiring strategy? Partner with CareerXperts to find the talent that will shape your future. Contact us today to redefine your talent acquisition strategy.
If you are a Founder, Hiring Manager, Employer, looking to hire Top Talent for your Startup, Write to us at info@careerxperts.com to get connected!
Here's a snapshot of what we're all about:
Treasury / Accounts / Audits / CRM ( Real Estate / Redevelopment ) AND Balanced Life & Time Management Coach
3dInteresting Let's connect