Federal Black Employee Caucus (FBEC) | Caucus des employés fédéraux noirs (CEFN) reposted this
50% of Black female Executive faced disciplinary investigations and 100% of those investigations were determined to be unfounded. This is incontrovertible evidence of institutional levers being weaponized against Black employees. Dr. Zellars study raises a lot of concerning questions: •Are organizations tracking disciplinary action data with self ID to identify disproportionate impact? •How are those who are weaponizing the system being held to account? •If this is how Black executives are being treated, what about those with less agency? Disaggregated data on disciplinary action is critical and identifying how systemic this issue is.
➡ Key finding: Formal and informal complaints are regularly being used, maliciously and vexatiously, to harm Black leaders. 100% of completed investigations documented during the study were unfounded. Initially, this study was scheduled to wrap up in December 2023. But, during interviews, an unexpected finding arose: Black executives shared the tremendous distress they experienced navigating formal complaint processes they described as deliberately harmful and that were ultimately determined to be unfounded. At the same time, BEN-REN also began documenting these experiences from its members. As I undertook another 30 interviews (Phase 2 of the study) focused on complaints, Black employees continued to email me in distress – to date, another dozen. Black leaders were subjected to 18 to 24 month invasive investigations. After being removed from their leadership positions. And after experiencing extreme health impacts – lasting depression, high blood pressure, diabetes, heart and breathing problems, suicidality – all caused by a humiliating, exhausting, isolating, and unjust complaint process. Importantly, complainants were never punished. Rather, they simply moved on to another position or retired. In the entire study, a striking 50% of Black female executives shared these experiences. Haitian women and African executives reported in disproportionately high numbers. Black men also described devastating experiences with lengthy complaint processes.