Great summary of some key questions about GenAI from Florian Stöckel
After a recent talk on leveraging GenAI in higher education that I gave, two familiar questions came up: 1) How should we handle essays that show signs of being generated by GenAI? 2) What do we do when students know more about GenAI than the faculty? The first issue is tricky; the second perhaps not so much. First off, as far as I know there’s currently no tool that can reliably identify if an essay was written by GenAI. Accusing students without sound proof can lead to legal problems (more on this, see links below). Instead, what we can do is discuss expectations upfront. If a text seems like a copy-paste from ChatGPT, it’s likely because it’s written poorly or the style feels off—which is both bad style and bad GenAI usage. If used well, GenAI should enhance the style, not make it worse. If we can't legally flag GenAI usage reliably, it's probably better to avoid the dilemma altogether: either permit and support(!) GenAI (with the expectation that good usage should lead to excellent results both with regard to accuracy and style!) or design assessments that avoid its use, like closed-book exams or oral formats. As for students knowing more about GenAI than their instructors—I’m absolutely assuming they do! And I think it’s great. Importantly, though, there’s often a big disparity in skills within a classroom. We can use this to create a level playing field where students help each other learn, and where faculty can engage with students on more equal footing, as both faculty and students have unique knowledge to share. This kind of dialogue can bridge faculty concerns—like accuracy, citation practices, and biases—with practical insights from proficient users! ➡️ If your institution or department is having these debates and you'd find some external input helpful, please let me know. 🤝 Some resources that might be useful On inability to detect GenAI generated output reliably: https://lnkd.in/e62KS25R (slide 12 and onwards) https://lnkd.in/epSg9SEb For an intuition how GenAI output is created: https://lnkd.in/ep5djyZn https://lnkd.in/e3BsEueZ #GenAI #HigherEducation #TeachingWithAI #AIinEducation #GenerativeAI #EdTech #AcademicIntegrity #StudentLearning #FutureOfEducation #ArtificialIntelligence #FacultyDevelopment #DigitalLiteracy #LearningTogether #AIUsageInClassroom