Rory Fitzgerald’s Post

View profile for Rory Fitzgerald, graphic

Freelance Creative Director and Motion Graphic Designer

Coca-Cola’s latest AI-generated Christmas ad has sparked heated debate—and not the merry kind. Meant to evoke the charm of their 1995 trucks, it instead veers into the uncanny valley. Described as “creepy” and a “dystopian nightmare,” it begs the question: if an agency had pitched this ad a few years ago, would they have been laughed out of the room for poor quality and execution? This misstep underscores a critical truth in the ongoing battle between AI and human creativity. While AI excels at speed, it falls short on the soul, emotion, and artistry that breathe life into storytelling. For creatives, this is a moral victory. It’s a clear reminder that human ingenuity is irreplaceable, and impactful advertising is built on connection—not algorithms. The takeaway? Technology should amplify creativity, not replace it. In this round, the dreamers win.

Joel Priestland

Brand and Creative Direction – Design Studio. Nura.

3w

It seemed the biggest cheer was the reveal that Santa had five fingers.

Alan MacEachern

Art Director/ Character Design/ 2dfx

3w

I think Coca Cola knew this looked creepy and a bit rubbish. Id be curious to know how many time this has been shared/viewed compared with previous Christmas campaigns as i reckon they're quite happy with all the attention this advert is getting.

Like
Reply
Andy Lynch

Senior Designer / Motion Graphics Specialist

3w

Thanks... I hate it 😅 hard to believe that would get past multiple approval rounds. Completely lifeless and the pace feels all wrong.

Adam Rael

Film Director & Co-Founder of Cassette Vision

3w

That's a great question regarding the poor quality and execution. It's effectively an advert made mostly of b-roll. In what other time would Coca-Cola have been okay with that standard?

Paul 'Nobby' Davies

The Creative Elder | Coach | Mentor | Confidant | Storyteller | Curator | Collaborator | Artist | Consultant

3w

I hope the AI doesn’t learn from this.

Brian Conlan

CEO at Glass Knight Digital Ltd Glass Knight Media

3w

It’s lifelessness is actually boring to watch.

Like
Reply
Hannah Ryan

Creative Producer 🎥

1w

Well said Rory ☘️

Manuela Savini

Head of Marketing & Customer Experience

3w

Yep! Just because you can, it doesn't mean you should #fakemagic

Just because you can, doesn't mean you should.

See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics