ACL Injury: Why me? Why now?
Written by Mick Hughes - www.mickhughes.physio

ACL Injury: Why me? Why now?

I had an interesting discussion over on LinkedIn recently about how ACL injuries occur despite the player performing the same change of direction/pivoting action "millions" of times.

 And it's a fair point: How can a player pivot without injury 1000 times in a season, yet the 1001st time that they pivot it ruptures their ACL?

 I don't know the answer; but sometimes an ACL injury is simply bad luck, and you'll drive yourself crazy trying to come up with an answer as to why it occurred.

 One big thing to understand is that, although there are many modifiable reasons as to why an ACL injury occurs (strength & muscular control being the 2 main players), there are also many NON-MODIFABLE factors as to why they occurred (anatomy, hormones, genetics), which we simply have no control over.

At the moment, the current evidence tells us this:

1) To reduce risk of primary ACL injury; 50% ACL injuries are reduced with neuromuscular training programs (think FIFA 11+, Netball Knee, AFL FOOTY FIRST). Minimum 30mins per week (or 10mins minimum before trainings and games)

 2) To reduce risk of ACL recurrences; wait 9 months before return to sport & pass a series of strength, hop and subjective questionnaires discharge criteria before return to sport.

 

As long as we all do this, we can sleep well at night. If we do more than this, then that's a bonus 👍


Luke Casley

Director at Morris Cohen Glen and Co

1y

interesting share Mick. Thank you.

Like
Reply
Kasim Suleiman Limako

American Council on Exercise(ACE)certified group&persoanal trainer,certificate No. F113210

6y

ACL is also common mostly due to muscular imbalance of the lower leg.in this situation bad luck and fatigue.

Like
Reply
Rebecca Crawford

Biomechanist | Scientist | Physiotherapist | Body Urbanist | Artist | Imaginator

6y

I'm a bit late to this thought-provoking post. Even the most well-trained athletes can succumb to less predictable extrinsic factors like turf (or landing) irregularities. Training must challenge responsive proprioception or 'bad luck' will happen unabated. This goes for everyone. #bodyurbanism

David Wasserstein

Orthopedic Surgeon, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre

6y

In this level of player it's likely due to fatigue and as you said, "bad luck", which is probably situational/positional. Nice article.

To view or add a comment, sign in

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics