The Loss of Education
HBR

The Loss of Education

An expanding economy and a growing middle class have left many of us confused here in India. The IIT’s thought to be the epitome of intellectual prowess in an aspirational country are generally in the news for all the right reasons. Many of the world’s foremost business leaders are from an IIT and they are celebrated as much as are their organisations; however that seems to have changed a tad yesterday. An IITian is alleged to have sent India’s cricket captain an e-threat where he allegedly threatened to rape Virat Kohli’s, year old daughter, for India having lost to Pakistan in a T-20 cricket game in the recent past. The sick man has since been arrested. Even considering the fact that the arrested person is very young the event is bothersome considering that the trigger was an innocuous event.

The point of discussion is why would an educated person carry out an act of lunacy such as this? We also have highly educated fraudsters and for that matter terrorists, which brings home the question, what is the purpose of education? Is acquiring a degree or two, education? Is there something else to sound learning and education and does it impact our lives?

The great thinker Jiddu Krishnamurthy, says that the purpose of education is to create an integrated human being or one who is well rounded with an ability to think originally. The issue as I can see it, in the present, is the lack of a well-rounded education with a broad latitude. Specialised learning offers more lucrative short-term returns, which makes it attractive to many in a country driven by pure aspiration for material well-being. Elon Musk once said "I hate when people confuse education with intelligence, you can have a bachelor's degree and still be an idiot". Krishnamurthy was of the opinion that many people fail to see the value of a broad and liberal education because their parents and teachers fail to do so, causing the rise of a generation of people who believe in an ideal life of well-being and happiness that only exists in the realms of fantasy and one in which originality of thought, ideas and action is missing. An idealists journey, in a world fraught with uncertainty and risk is one of pathos and doubt even as he/she chases that elusive idea at the expense of all else. An idealist fails to appreciate diversion points of view and this eventually leads to issues in a naturally diverse world which has been brought closer due to digitisation and various communication channels in use.

There is an urgent need to shift away from narrowly focussed education and move towards a more broad-based one. After all a recent study from the USA, suggests that those people with better social skills seem to make more money. That should be an incentive in a hard-nosed world. Mark Twain said “I have never let my schooling interfere with my education.” Maybe it’s time to reclaim our schools and colleges from overzealous specialists who are driven by the short and narrow. There are too many unhappy educated folk, in broken relationships, disgruntled in their jobs and burnt-out, for us not to take notice.

Excellent points to ponder upon Captain. Best educated from top institutions doesn’t equate to well rounded human being in the society. Moral science, ethics and law need to be taught to children from a young age. World and Indian History should be taught from a different angle. I would say. Not just dates what happened? when? rather bring out great leaders, their ethical and moral values etc.,. Similar to our OB classes done by you Captain. A bit of physology also would be great since it would make people think deeper.

Shankar H N

Network Management specialization and and adjunct faculty in Dayananda Sagar University in Ops Management and IT.

3y

Very true. People are looking at credentials but not not honest in developing capabilities.

Like
Reply
Prof Archie D'Souza

Expert in Project & Supply Chain Management and Blockchain Technology, SCM Consultant & Author

3y

Great points raised, all very pertinent. However, I'd say, one can't blame an IIT (I'm not saying you did either) for a few rotten eggs. I remember an incident, not too long ago, when a student of IIT, Madras (my daughter too was there then) made a public proclamation saying he had broken off and was celebrating his independence. The girl committed suicide and the social media was filled with hate messages against the IITs in general. We need to condemn the person and the incident, not the institution. As far as the education system is concerned, even if ethics and morals are drilled repeatedly into people's heads, there will be some very rotten apples in the basket. I liked the illustration. Who's artwork is it? Once again, I say, great points raised

Cdr Himanshu Joshi

Founder: Vadamoola Productivity Solutions (P) Ltd. Adjunct faculty : School of Commerce & Mgt. Studies, Dayanand Sagar Univt. Visiting :Cadeto India.

3y

A worthy piece of literature in current times. One is tempted to use the word 'sanskar' which ultimately means values which affect behavioural attributes. Somewhere in the desire to achieve higher percentages of literacy, the proponents of education as is, forgot this aspect and the term got relegated to a means of acquiring material ends. From joint to nuclear and thereafter multi income family formats eroded the system of transference of values onto the younger generation which now is addressed as x, y & z. Academic institutions using the platform of education as business have also contributed largely to this value depletion. So it is not surprising that the youngster emerging out of a trusted brand of academic canvas has chosen to paint that canvas dirty. While you have focused on education exclusively, I'd like to go a step further to suggest that the malaise has infected a broader spectrum. Look at the debates (if you can call them so) that honourable legislators engage in, whether in parliament, assembly or on discussion forums. To me it looks like there's a need to revamp not just the educational philosophy but the entire social configuration starting from the smallest societal unit- 'the family'. Thought provoking piece.

Dr. CBV Krishna Prasad

A passionate Management Teacher

3y

Sir, Well crafted article. In the process of acquiring Degrees, Many are missing the Purpose of Education - Thinking and Learning.

To view or add a comment, sign in

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics