The Monkey Experiment That Transformed My Leadership: The Science of Motivation

What truly motivates a team to perform at their best? Is it rewards, penalties, or something deeper? Leadership often involves navigating the complexities of motivation, but what if the answer lies in something as simple—and profound—as a monkey experiment?

---

It was 2017, and I had just been seconded to a new organization. As part of my role, I was scheduled to meet each of my team members individually to understand their goals, challenges, and aspirations. I started with one particular team member over a casual coffee during her work appraisal. We spoke about her progress and what she hoped to achieve in the months ahead. Toward the end of our conversation, I mentioned something fascinating I had recently read—an experiment involving monkeys and puzzles. Intrigued, she leaned forward and asked, “What happened with the monkeys?”

I explained how researchers gave a group of monkeys a simple mechanical puzzle that involved pulling out a pin, undoing a latch, and lifting a cover. To everyone’s surprise, the monkeys tackled the puzzles without any training, rewards, or prompting. They simply engaged with the puzzles because solving them was inherently enjoyable.

“Why would they do it if they weren’t getting anything out of it?” she asked, a mix of curiosity and amusement on her face.

I paused, smiled, and said, “That’s what’s so fascinating. It wasn’t about survival or rewards—there was something else going on.” When she asked what the researchers concluded, I laughed and admitted, “I haven’t finished the book yet.” We both laughed, but the question lingered in my mind.

---

In Drive, Daniel Pink outlined the two dominant theories of motivation at the time of the monkey experiments. The first theory was that behavior is driven by biological needs, such as hunger, thirst, and safety. By this reasoning, the monkeys should have only worked on the puzzles if it satisfied some basic necessity. However, the puzzles provided no biological benefit.

The second theory focused on external rewards and punishments—the classic carrot-and-stick approach. This theory suggested that behavior is shaped by incentives or consequences. Yet, the monkeys worked on the puzzles with no reward or penalty involved.

These theories couldn’t explain the monkeys’ behavior. That’s when researchers uncovered a third motivation theory: intrinsic motivation. This theory proposes that people—and, apparently, monkeys—are driven by the joy of the task itself. Intrinsic motivation arises from within, fueled by the satisfaction of engaging in a meaningful activity, learning something new, or solving a challenge.

Pink built on this idea by showing that intrinsic motivation is also a powerful force in humans, especially when three key factors are present:

1. Autonomy: People are motivated when they have control over how they approach their work. Trust and freedom spark creativity and engagement.

2. Mastery: The natural human desire to improve, learn, and grow fuels long-term effort and enthusiasm. Opportunities to build skills and tackle challenges energize people.

3. Purpose: Connecting work to a greater mission or meaning inspires commitment. When people feel their efforts make a difference, they find deeper satisfaction in their work.

---

As the series of meetings with my team members continued, I found myself retelling this story—only this time, I began sharing the progress of my reading and what I was learning along the way. Each meeting gave me an opportunity to reflect on the concepts I was uncovering in Drive by Daniel Pink, and I couldn’t help but connect these lessons to my team’s work.

These conversations sparked two important shifts in me. First, I began to truly understand what intrinsic motivation is and how it shapes behavior. I saw how tasks that give people a sense of control, opportunities to grow, and a connection to a larger goal inspire more than any external reward ever could. Second, it set me on a journey of learning. That initial exploration of Drive led me to read more books about leadership, motivation, and communication. Over time, these lessons transformed how I approached leadership and inspired me to share these reflections with others. In many ways, those coffee conversations are the reason I write these newsletters today.

---

Here are my three tips on leadership communication to foster motivation:

Encourage ownership in decision-making: Autonomy is key. Allow your team to decide how they approach their work, while you focus on setting clear goals and outcomes. Trust them to find their own path and share your confidence in their abilities.

Provide growth-oriented challenges: Create opportunities for mastery by assigning tasks that stretch their current abilities. Celebrate progress, provide constructive feedback, and help them learn from setbacks. Growth happens when people feel supported in taking on challenges.

Connect their efforts to a meaningful goal: Purpose fuels inspiration. Regularly link your team’s work to the organization’s mission or customer impact. Use storytelling to show how their contributions make a real difference.

---

Good leadership requires the regular checking of the vital signs of the team. Autonomy, mastery, and purpose act as its heartbeat, temperature, and blood pressure—key indicators of team health. When these elements are balanced, the team thrives with energy, focus, and engagement. By monitoring these signs, leaders can ensure their teams flourish and achieve sustainable success.