Why Negotiations Fail

Welcome to Leading Engineers - a weekly newsletter specifically for engineering leaders who want to increase your impact at every level of the organization.  Each week you’ll gain powerful strategies, techniques, and insights for driving your team, company, and career forward!

This week's topic: Why Negotiations Fail 

Negotiations are a critical component of engineering management, affecting everything from project scopes and deadlines to resource allocations and vendor contracts. However, despite their importance, many negotiations fail to reach a satisfactory conclusion.

Here are the most common reasons behind unsuccessful negotiations in the context of engineering management, shedding light on the pitfalls that even seasoned managers might encounter.

Common Reasons Behind Unsuccessful Negotiations:

1. Poor Preparation:

A lack of thorough preparation is often the biggest downfall in negotiation scenarios. Engineering managers might enter negotiations without a clear understanding of their objectives, the needs of the other party, or the constraints and possibilities of the agreement. According to a survey by KPMG, 83% of their respondents agreed that poor preparation was the most common reason for failure in negotiations.

2. Inadequate Understanding of Stakeholder Needs:

Engineering projects involve multiple stakeholders, each with their own set of expectations and requirements. Failing to understand or consider these can lead to proposals that are outright rejected. As noted by Harvard Business Review, "Neglecting the stakeholders’ needs is akin to setting the stage for failure. Successful negotiations hinge on the ability of the negotiator to align their proposals with the expectations of all parties involved."

3. Lack of Clear Communication:

Miscommunications or the absence of clear, assertive dialogue can result in misunderstandings that derail negotiations. This is particularly prevalent in engineering, where technical details and project specifics need to be communicated with precision. A study by the American Management Association reveals that 48% of negotiation failures are due to miscommunication or poor communication strategies.

4. Rigid Negotiation Tactics:

Overly rigid negotiation tactics, where a manager might stick too strictly to initial demands or guidelines, can impede the development of mutually beneficial solutions. Flexibility often facilitates better outcomes. In a high-profile project failure, inflexibility on delivery deadlines led to the cancellation of a major engineering contract, illustrating how unyielding demands can lead to negotiation breakdowns.

5. Emotional Decision-Making:

Allowing emotions to drive decisions, rather than rational analysis, can compromise the negotiation's outcomes. Engineering managers may react emotionally to pressure or perceived slights, which can cloud judgment. Studies in decision-making psychology suggest that emotional reactions are less likely to result in rational, beneficial outcomes. According to Dr. Linda Elder with the Foundation for Critical Thinking, "Emotion-driven negotiations often overlook logical solutions and harm professional relationships."

6. Underestimating the Complexity of Engineering Projects:

Non-engineers or stakeholders not fully acquainted with the project's technical aspects might not grasp the negotiation's complexity. This can lead to unrealistic demands or commitments that are not feasible, causing negotiations to stall or fail. As per a report by the Construction Industry Institute, over 30% of failed engineering negotiations were attributed to stakeholders having a poor understanding of project complexities.

Understanding these common pitfalls can enlighten engineering managers about what to avoid in their future negotiations. While this article does not delve into specific negotiation strategies, recognizing these mistakes is the first step towards more successful outcomes in managing engineering projects.

Engineering managers, by being aware of these issues, can better navigate the complexities of negotiations and lead their projects toward successful completions.

Negotiating can be challenging, but with the right tools and strategies, you can handle any negotiation scenario with confidence. 

In my recent YouTube episode, “9 Powerful Negotiating Tools and Strategies”, I break down nine powerful negotiation tools from the book "Never Split the Difference" by Chris Voss. Learn how to apply these tactics to achieve better outcomes in your professional and personal negotiations.

WATCH NOW!

- Doug Howard PE

PS - If you want to learn more about this topic, and gain access to bonus material, free training resources, and special offers - subscribe to the Leading Engineers email list CLICK HERE