Weekly power simulation, week 22 of 2024 Let's talk about ramp speeds. How fast a change in generation (or demand) can the energy system cope with? This Sunday, high output from wind and solar, along with the low weekend demand meant spot prices went negative in Denmark for 3 hours, between 13:00 and 16:00. Most large renewable generators reacted by ramping down generation, though some kept producing, probably due to PPAs. This can be seen as a massive 'spike' in our simulation on Sunday, as renewable generation ramps down a massive 10.8GW in a single hour(!). And while this is in fact just a functioning market, it does beg the question: How fast ramp up/down can the grid handle? Looking at historical data, April 10th this year jumps out as the fastest ever 'ordinary' ramp-down rate of renewable generation (i.e. excluding curtailment and negative prices). This happened as winds died down in the late afternoon, just as the sun was setting - compounding solar and wind's ramp-down. In just four hours, between 14:00 and 19:00, renewable output dropped from 7.7GW to 2.7GW. In just 30 minutes, between 16:45 and 17:15, 870MW went offline in a grid app. 4.5GW demand(!). What 'saved' us was primarily Danish interconnections, ramping from exporting 2.5GW to importing 0.6GW in the same time span. It does have it's advantages being as interconnected to neighboring countries as Denmark. Of course, in our 'future' scenario, storage and demand side flexibility will play an increasing role in coping with such fast changes in output from solar and wind, potentially even more than our interconnectors. ----- Each week, I run a simulation using real-world generation data from the Danish power grid, with #windenergy and #solarenergy scaled to match future (2033) capacities, as forecasted by the Danish Energy Agency. See earlier posts by searching for #WeeklyPowerSimulation. The original idea for such a simplified, but very illustrative, simulation is David Osmond's from Australian Windlab. His version is found on twitter here: https://t.co/5Y3UiKB5Di
How to Deal with Fast Ramp Speeds? Let's look at California. The first chart below shows how steep the duck curve has become, now referred to as a "Canyon Curve." The second chart (next reply) illustrates how rapidly batteries have been deployed to support and mitigate the challenges posed by the Canyon Curve. This transformation is unfolding right before our eyes in 2024. The only question is how quickly we in Europe can adopt the measures California is already implementing.
External Affairs Manager | Ørsted
6mo... and here's the actual situation on April 10th 2024