How Do You Measure the True Success of Coaching?

Coaching, once a niche service reserved for elite athletes and top-level executives, has become a global phenomenon. Its' application spans industries and professions, offering tailored guidance for personal and professional growth. As the coaching industry continues to grow. understanding how to measure the true success of coaching becomes increasingly important. But what does success in coaching look like? How can organisations and individuals determine if coaching has been truly effective?

The Rise and Value of Coaching

The coaching industry has seen explosive growth over the last two decades, driven by demand from individuals, organisations, and executives seeking personal and professional development. According to the International Coaching Federation (ICF), the global coaching industry was valued at approximately $2.8 billion in 2019, with an estimated 71,000 professional coaches worldwide. The most recent revenue estimate for the global coaching industry was in 2023 at $4.5billion with an estimated 109,000 practitioners. Between 2019 and 2023, the growth in revenue and certified practitioners reflects its increasing popularity as a critical component in leadership development and personal transformation.

In the UK, the coaching industry has also seen substantial growth. According to a study by IBISWorld, the life coaching market in the UK grew steadily, driven by the increasing adoption of coaching services by businesses and individuals. The Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD) reports that around 55% of organisations in the UK use coaching in their development programs, highlighting its role in enhancing employee performance and well-being.

With the growing recognition of coaching as a valuable tool, the question arises: How do we measure its success?

Key Ways to Measure the Success of Coaching

Measuring the success of coaching can be challenging, as it involves both qualitative and quantitative outcomes. Success is not limited to tangible achievements but also encompasses personal growth and emotional well-being. Below are some key ways that can be used to assess the effectiveness of coaching and potential pros and cons:

1. Achievement of Specific Goals

One of the most straightforward ways to measure the success of coaching is by evaluating whether specific, pre-defined goals have been achieved. Coaching often begins with the establishment of measurable objectives, such as improving leadership skills, developing better communication abilities, or increasing emotional intelligence. Success can be tracked through goal-setting frameworks like SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound), which provide clear benchmarks for success.

For instance, a 2016 study published in the Journal of Applied Behavioural Science demonstrated that goal attainment is a significant predictor of coaching success. In this study, participants who set clear objectives were more likely to report positive outcomes and higher levels of satisfaction with their coaching experience.

Pros:

Clarity and Focus: Measuring coaching success by goal achievement offers clear, measurable outcomes. It provides both the coach and the coachee with a shared understanding of what success looks like. By using frameworks like SMART, clients can work toward specific milestones, and progress is easy to track and document.

Objective Measurement: Since goals are often specific and quantifiable (e.g., increased sales by 10%, delivered a successful project), this method provides objective data that organisations can use to justify investments in coaching.

Cons:

Narrow Focus: Focusing too much on achieving specific goals can narrow the coaching scope. Some valuable outcomes, like emotional resilience or improved interpersonal relationships, may not be reflected in goal-oriented metrics.

External Factors: Achievement of goals can sometimes depend on factors outside the coachee's control, such as changes in the economy or organisational shifts. A missed goal doesn't necessarily mean that coaching has failed, but it can be perceived that way.

Short-Term Focus: Setting overly specific goals can push individuals to pursue short-term wins, potentially at the expense of long-term personal or career growth. This method may neglect slower, deeper changes that come with time.

2. Improvement in Job Performance

Another key indicator of coaching success is improvement in job performance. In professional settings, coaching is often used to enhance leadership, team collaboration, time management, or decision-making skills. Evaluating success in this domain can involve tracking key performance indicators (KPIs) or other metrics such as sales figures, productivity rates, or project completion times.

A 2020 ICF Global Coaching Study found that 60% of organisations that implement coaching report improved individual performance, while 40% report an increase in employee engagement. Additionally, companies using coaching often see improved retention rates, as employees feel more supported and empowered in their roles. This improvement in job performance is particularly valued in executive and leadership coaching, where the impact of individual performance can cascade throughout an entire organisation.

Furthermore, an evaluation of a coaching program at a UK-based financial services firm, cited in a 2017 report by the Institute for Employment Studies (IES), showed a 30% improvement in leadership performance as measured by pre- and post-coaching assessments. This improvement was attributed directly to the coaching interventions that focused on key leadership competencies.

Pros:

Direct Organisational Impact: Improved job performance is often seen as a primary outcome of coaching, especially in corporate settings. Enhanced leadership, communication, and decision-making skills directly contribute to improved productivity and profitability, making it easier to justify coaching investments to boards and stakeholders.

Quantifiable Metrics: Performance improvements can often be measured through Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), 360-degree feedback, or regular performance appraisals. This makes it possible to produce data that aligns with organisational goals.

Cons:

Difficulty in Attribution: It can be difficult to attribute job performance improvements solely to coaching. Other variables, such as workplace changes, training, or the influence of colleagues, may also contribute to an employee's success. Isolating the impact of coaching can be challenging.

Limited Scope: Similar to goal achievement, a focus on job performance might ignore other forms of personal or professional growth that are less immediately visible but still significant (e.g., increased emotional intelligence or enhanced adaptability).

Pressure to Deliver: There may be undue pressure on the coachee to demonstrate quantifiable job performance improvements, leading to stress or a focus on immediate results rather than sustainable development.

3. Personal Growth and Clarity

While professional success is often the primary goal of coaching, personal growth is an equally important measure of success. Coaching helps individuals gain clarity about their values, strengths, and areas for improvement. This can lead to increased self-awareness, confidence, and emotional resilience. Personal growth is often more difficult to quantify, but it can be measured through self-assessments and reflective practices. Many coaches use psychometric assessments or journaling exercises to help clients track changes in mindset and emotional well-being over time.

A study by the American Psychological Association (APA) in 2018 found that coaching participants experienced significant improvements in well-being, life satisfaction, and stress reduction. These personal gains contribute to long-term success, as individuals who develop greater emotional intelligence and self-awareness are more likely to succeed both personally and professionally.

Likewise, a 2019 study published in The Leadership Quarterly highlighted the importance of personal development as a measure of coaching success. The study found that leaders who engaged in coaching reported greater clarity about their purpose and values, which in turn translated into improved decision-making and enhanced leadership capabilities.

Pros:

Holistic Development: Personal growth, including increased self-awareness, emotional intelligence, and mental clarity, is a critical aspect of coaching. This leads to long-term, sustainable benefits for both the individual and the organisation, as employees who feel more confident and aligned with their values tend to perform better over time.

Intrinsic Value: Personal growth often brings intrinsic rewards, such as improved well-being and work-life balance. These benefits enhance overall job satisfaction and engagement, which can indirectly contribute to organisational success.

 Cons:

Subjective Measurement: Personal growth is difficult to measure objectively. It often relies on self-reported assessments or reflective exercises, which can be biased or inconsistent. Without hard data, personal growth may be undervalued in corporate settings where quantifiable metrics are prioritised.

Less Immediate Organisational Impact: While personal growth has long-term benefits, it may not yield immediate returns in terms of job performance or goal achievement. Organisations may struggle to justify the time and cost invested in coaching that focuses heavily on personal development without visible, short-term results.

4. Career Progression and Development

Coaching is often sought to facilitate career progression, whether that involves transitioning to a new role, gaining a promotion, or developing leadership capabilities. Evaluating success in this area can be done through tracking career milestones such as promotions, salary increases, or taking on new responsibilities.

A 2019 meta-analysis conducted by The Henley Business School, focusing on executive coaching, found that 86% of coachees reported tangible career improvements, including promotions and increased responsibilities, following a coaching engagement. Furthermore, many individuals credited coaching with helping them navigate complex career decisions, enabling them to achieve greater clarity and alignment with their career goals.

A survey by the Association for Coaching (AC) in 2021 indicated that over 70% of coaching clients in the UK reported enhanced career progression as a result of their coaching engagements, either by securing new roles or advancing within their current organizations.

Pros:

Tangible Outcomes: Career progression is a clear and observable outcome of successful coaching. Promotions, increased responsibilities, or role transitions are milestones that provide concrete evidence of the coaching's impact on an individual’s career trajectory.

Enhanced Retention and Engagement: When employees experience career advancement through coaching, they tend to feel more valued by their organization, leading to higher engagement and retention rates. This aligns with broader organizational goals of talent development and succession planning.

Cons:

External Variables: Career progression often depends on external factors like organizational restructuring, available opportunities, or market conditions. As a result, not all career advancements can be attributed to coaching alone. Failure to progress may also be wrongly interpreted as coaching failure.

Focus on Advancement Over Development: In some cases, individuals or organizations may equate success with moving up the career ladder, overlooking the deeper personal growth that coaching fosters. This could result in short-sighted career decisions or unrealistic expectations.

Alternative Ways to Measure Coaching Success

Given the nuanced nature of coaching, additional ways to measure success may be necessary, particularly when the focus is reduced to simple figures on a spreadsheet. These approaches help to provide a more comprehensive evaluation of coaching's impact:

1.      Behavioural Change and Leadership Assessments

Measuring changes in behaviour and leadership style can be a more nuanced way of assessing coaching success. Tools such as 360-degree feedback assessments or leadership development programs can track observable changes in how individuals lead, communicate, and manage teams. Behavioural assessments can reveal shifts in interpersonal dynamics, emotional intelligence, and adaptability—factors that contribute to long-term leadership success but may not immediately translate into financial metrics.

2.      Qualitative Interviews and Testimonials

Sometimes, success is best captured through qualitative means. Conducting in-depth interviews or gathering testimonials from coachees can provide insights into the personal and professional impact of coaching that may not show up in performance metrics. These narratives often offer deeper insight on how coaching has helped individuals navigate complex challenges, clarify their goals, or redefine their sense of purpose.

3.      Longitudinal Studies

The benefits of coaching are often more apparent over the long term. Longitudinal studies that track individuals or teams over several months or years can offer a more complete picture of the coaching process and its lasting impact. Such studies can provide evidence of sustained improvements in performance, personal growth, and career progression, which may not be immediately visible in short-term evaluations.

Conclusion

The success of coaching is multi-dimensional and extends beyond simple performance metrics. While achievement of specific goals and improvement in job performance are essential indicators, personal growth, emotional well-being, and career development are equally important measures of coaching success. To truly gauge the effectiveness of coaching, both qualitative and quantitative factors must be considered.

As the coaching industry continues to expand globally and within the UK, the ability to measure its success will become increasingly crucial for individuals and organisations alike. By incorporating methods such as behavioural assessments, ROI analysis, and qualitative feedback, organisations and individuals can better understand the broader, long-term impact of coaching. Ultimately, the true success of coaching lies in fostering sustainable personal and professional growth, creating a ripple effect that benefits both individuals and the organisations they contribute to.

About Me:

I am a Professional Career Coach and NLP Practitioner with 20 years’ experience in senior business roles in the recruitment and executive search industry.

Today I help professionals and executives to achieve their career goals or make the change if their career is no longer in alignment with who they are.

➕ to follow

🔔 to be notified when I post

📧 to discover how I could help your or your organisation